| ABOUT US | ARCHIVES | LINKS | RSS FEED | MONDAYS | |

3quarksdaily

An Eclectic Digest of Science, Art and Literature

« Chef of the North: An Interview with Karen Peters | Main | Now That's a Party Animal »

July 28, 2008

Tongues of Fire, Plains of Grace: Remembering Hiroshima and Nagasaki

Screenhunter_06_jul_28_1841Sixty-three years ago on August 6, the first atomic bomb was dropped on Hiroshima. Three days later, a second atomic bomb was dropped on Nagasaki. The bombs, upon contact with the earth, appeared as brilliant flashes that incinerated living beings and urban life within seconds. Those who did not die immediately, suffered slow, excruciating death from exposure to high-levels of radiation. Present generations continue to suffer the affects of the bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki, Japan more than six decades ago.

In May 1945, The Target Committee at Los Alamos led by Robert Oppenheimer, deliberated on which cities would receive the bombs. Hiroshima, Niigata, Yokohama, and the Japanese city of temples, Kyoto, were top contenders as they met the following requirements:

"(1) they are larger than three miles in diameter and are important targets in a large urban area (2) the blast would create effective damage, and (3) they are unlikely to be attacked by August 1945."

In addition, the cities chosen needed to be new targets; the sixty-seven Japanese cities that had received intense firebombing were precluded from selection.

The decision to drop bombs on urban centers killed more than human beings. In the words of Hannah Arendt:

"In the case of an atomic bombing...a community does not merely receive an impact; the community itself is destroyed. Within 2 kilometers of the atomic bomb's hypocenter all life and property were shattered, burned, and buried under ashes. The visible forms of the city where people once carried on their daily lives vanished without a trace. The destruction was sudden and thorough; there was virtually no chance to escape....Citizens who had lost no family members in the holocaust were as rare as stars at sunrise....
The atomic bomb had blasted and burned hospitals, schools, city offices, police stations, and every other kind of human organization....Family, relatives, neighbors, and friends relied on a broad range of interdependent organizations for everything from birth, marriage, and funerals to firefighting, productive work, and daily living. These traditional communities were completely demolished in an instant."

In the days between bombs, American forces in the Marianas devised a leaflet to be dropped on Japanese cities. The leaflet used a combination of kanji and kana characters and was produced on a printing press previously used to publish a Japanese-language newspaper. On August 7, a team working on behalf of the U.S. War Department in generating psychological warfare, worked overtime producing the leaflets. Their plan was to drop 6 million of them over forty-seven cities with populations over 100,000. The following is a translated excerpt:

"ATTENTION JAPANESE PEOPLE

Before we use this bomb again and again to destroy every resource of the military by which they are prolonging this useless war, petition the Emperor now to end the war. Our President has outlined for you the thirteen consequences of an honorable surrender; We urge that you accept those consequences and begin the work of building a new, better, and peace loving Japan.

Act at once or we shall resolutely employ this bomb and all our other superior weapons to promptly and forcefully end the war.

EVACUATE YOUR CITIES"

Two days to print and drop leaflets was not much time; even less so for the Japanese people to act upon circumstance in the many ways the leaflet suggested. A shortage of T-3 leaflet bombs also presented a snag in the delivery timeline. Nagasaki received its quota of leaflets on August 10.

Freshly printed paper falling from the sky was perhaps the only unscorched, unread gesture left in the aftermath of Fat Man's shadow.

***

I have seen a replica of Fat Man in a museum in Los Alamos, New Mexico. More important, I have seen the affects of a replica of the atomic bomb on a multigenerational Japanese family assembled around it, holding hands. With heads bowed, the grandfather reached out his hand, the one that wasn't connecting all the other hands, and extended it over the museum-quality velvet maroon rope, and on to the bulky body of Fat Man. As he laid his hand on the replica atomic bomb it sent a current of deep collective grief through each family member.

This moment was real. And so too, unfortunately and grotesquely so, were the lollipops for sale in the gift shop in the shape of Little Boy and Fat Man.

I had initially come to New Mexico to meet with a Navajo Code Talker. The Code Talkers used their native tongue to relay messages on ships and on the ground in the Pacific theater during World War II. They were needed to help clear the islands. The islands needed to be cleared so that the airplanes carrying the atomic bombs could load and refuel before reaching the main island of Japan. The record of translation by the Code Talkers from English to Navajo back to English remains at 100% accuracy.

While a majority of Code Talkers returned home to the four-states region of the Navajo Nation after the war had been declared over, two were sent to Japan to relay in code the affects of radiation on the Japanese people back to the scientific community without detection.

When I ask my friend about what he felt about being admonished as a child at the BIA boarding school for speaking Navajo and then later rewarded in war for using it to such successful ends, he said it had been resolved because, "Nobody has ever been able to steal the Navajo language." "Why can't it be stolen?," I asked. "Because it comes from the heart, the mind, and the tongue, leaving no other record." And because of this, he added, "only the speaker and the people closest to him can unlock its true meaning."

Language, it could be said, is the premier urban center kept alive by the community of people using it. How far does it extend and by what means? In honor of my Navajo friend, and all other urban centers kept intact by decent, daily observances, I sign off with the following Navajo [Dine] prayer:

"We are the Dine. Our endurance lies in our beliefs, prayers, chants, language and wisdom. Holding these truths, we return to our homeland within our sacred mountains. Our strength endures everlasting.

(each line is said while turning toward each of the four directions)

In beauty we walk,
In beauty we walk,
In beauty we walk,
In beauty we walk"

Laray Polk lives in Dallas, Texas. She can be contacted at laraypolk@earthlink.net

Posted by Laray Polk at 12:24 PM | Permalink

Comments

The bombs, upon contact with the earth, appeared as brilliant flashes that incinerated living beings and urban life within seconds.
Sorry to quibble on this topic, but both Hiroshima and Nagasaki were air bursts, 1,900 feet for Hiroshima and a bit less for Nagasaki. Ground burst and air burst have substantially different properties, especially for fall out.

Posted by: stefan | Jul 28, 2008 12:41:14 PM

Thanks, Stefan. I consulted Richard Rhodes' book, The Making of the Atomic Bomb, and found these passages:

"Little Boy exploded at 8:16:02 Hiroshima time, 43 seconds after it left the Enola Gay, 1.900 feet above the courtyard of Shima hospital...with a yield equivalent to 12,500 tons of TNT."

"Fat Man dropped from the B-29, fell through the hole and exploded 1,650 feet above the steep slopes of the city at 11:02 a.m., August 9, 1945....The steep hills confined the larger explosion; it caused less damage and loss of life than Little Boy."

Just as you had suggested. Will keep this in mind for future writings on the subject. Gravitational bombs have made a psychological impression that is hard to shake.

Posted by: Laray Polk | Jul 28, 2008 1:11:23 PM

Thank you.

Posted by: Pete Chapman | Jul 28, 2008 2:26:46 PM

Your descriptions of the Japanese family at the New Mexico museum and the Navajo Code Talker add new meanings to this by now rather jaded subject.

I still remember the impact I felt at the Hiroshima museum which contains remnants of the blast. Seeing actual pieces of clothing of victims, knapsacks of schoolchildren torn in pieces, and shadows of victims etched into pieces of concrete sidewalk brought the event home to me in a way that nothing else could. I hope that many 3QD readers can have that experience.

Note the expression "destroy every resource of the military" in the American leaflet. Yes, military resources were destroyed, but that could have been done by smaller conventional bombs as had been done up to then. The purpose of the atomic bombs was obviously, as Arendt says, to obliterate masses of civilians instantly, rather than over longer periods, as had already been done in the bombing of Tokyo and other Japanese cities, modeled on the bombing of Guernica, London, Hamburg, and many other cities on the other side of the world. The purpose was to escalate the terror of air warfare in an unprecedented degree -- "shock and awe" 20th-century-style.

In the Hiroshima Peace Park there is an inscription to the victims: "Rest in peace; the mistake will not be repeated." I beg to differ, though. It was not a mistake -- it was a deliberate, carefully considered action.

Posted by: JonJ | Jul 28, 2008 6:25:32 PM

"It was not a mistake -- it was a deliberate, carefully considered action."

... because something was done deliberately disqualifies it from being considered a bad decision? Since when did carefully calculated intent preclude carefully calculated mistakes?

Posted by: reader | Jul 28, 2008 6:46:15 PM

I just don't think that "mistake" or "error" is an adequate word for such things. Was Abu Ghraib a mistake? Just a goof-up? Is war a "mistake," like putting on mismatching socks?

Posted by: JonJ | Jul 28, 2008 11:54:34 PM

The Japanese invasion of China (also known as WWII) killed millions of Chinese. Wikipedia says about 20 million.

If the bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki shortened the war by a week or two, they probably saved more Chinese lives than the Japanese lives that they took.

AAV

Posted by: an alternate view | Jul 30, 2008 9:17:35 AM

Thanks, AAV.

The core aspect of this essay is about the known aspects of the dropping of the atomic bombs. We could easily throw out hypotheticals, contingencies, and mathematical probabilities based on knowns all day long. I can only know from direct experience what the known factors are, that is, what the human consequences of such actions has been. This is quite different than a distinct political perspective that includes strategy and justifications for why particular decisions were made based on projection. Bottom-line: People continue to suffer the affects of the bombs dropped on Hiroshima and Nagasaki. This includes the people in the planes who were following orders to drop them to the Code Talkers who participated in clearing the islands so that they could be dropped.

We can surmise, as with any war, that the people living in these heavily populated urban centers were not particularly political. Ordinary people going about daily life the best they could under the circumstances. Nonetheless, they became political targets. We can extend similar grief when considering the Chinese people during the same time period.

Howard Zinn has written on the subject of the increased civilian populations that are bombed with each successive war. For instance, in World War I, civilian casualties due to bombing represented about 10% whereas the percentage is 80-95% in the present day Iraq and Afghanistan wars. We know so much about war and its devastating affects yet we appear to know very little on what to do to prevent it.

Posted by: Laray Polk | Jul 30, 2008 11:36:36 AM

Though they may be brainwashed into waving flags, ordinary people never initiate wars. They are always started by elite groups in a country with a monopoly on wealth and power. Wars will end when the large majority of people in every country who have no desire for it reject the call of elites to war.

Posted by: Jared | Jul 30, 2008 1:05:16 PM

Post a comment






Subscribe to this blog's feed  

PayAnywhere with iphone credit card swiper

Android Tablet

Bluetooth Headset

2013 New Style Dresses

Compare Car Rental Prices

DHgate.com Wholesale

3QD on Facebook

3QD on Kindle

3QD by Daily Email

Receive all blogposts at the same time every day.

Enter your Email:


Preview 3QD Email

3QD on Twitter

Miscellany

Lijit Search

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

Add to Google

Recent Comments

araldo on Mohsin Hamid: 'Islam is not a monolith'

Dr. X, Ph.D. on Race Is Not Biology

jo smith on Physicists Create Quantum Link Between Photons That Don't Exist at the Same Time

jo smith on Mohsin Hamid: 'Islam is not a monolith'

Dr. Smith on Race Is Not Biology

Sundar on Daniel Dennett's seven tools for thinking

Sundar on Daniel Dennett's seven tools for thinking

Sundar on Why race as a biological construct matters

Sundar on Race Is Not Biology

Joel Grant on Why Rational People Buy Into Conspiracy Theories

khaled on Evolution shapes new rules for ant behavior

musafir on Mohsin Hamid: 'Islam is not a monolith'

araldo on Mohsin Hamid: 'Islam is not a monolith'

JM on Physicists Create Quantum Link Between Photons That Don't Exist at the Same Time

SteveRR on Daniel Dennett's seven tools for thinking

jo smith on Mohsin Hamid: 'Islam is not a monolith'

Grace on Daniel Dennett's seven tools for thinking

Elatia Harris on Daniel Dennett's seven tools for thinking

Abbas Raza on Daniel Dennett's seven tools for thinking

Jonathan on Daniel Dennett's seven tools for thinking

Bill on Daniel Dennett's seven tools for thinking

Louise Gordon on The need for critical science journalism

omar on Mohsin Hamid: 'Islam is not a monolith'

Jonathan on Daniel Dennett's seven tools for thinking

Bill on Daniel Dennett's seven tools for thinking

Acclaim For 3QD


"I couldn't tear myself away from 3 Quarks Daily, to the point of neglecting my work. Congratulations on this superb site."—Steven Pinker, Johnstone Professor of Psychology, Harvard University.

"I have placed 3 Quarks Daily at the head of my list of web bookmarks."—Richard Dawkins, Charles Simonyi Professor of the Public Understanding of Science at Oxford University.

"Just wanted you to know I’m one of many who reads and enjoys 3 Quarks....almost daily."—David Byrne, musician, former lead-singer of the Talking Heads, artist, intellectual.

Read more here.

The 3QD Prizes

Subscribe to this blog's feed