| ABOUT US | ARCHIVES | LINKS | RSS FEED | MONDAYS | |

3quarksdaily

An Eclectic Digest of Science, Art and Literature

« The Bush Administration steps up its secret moves against Iran | Main | qana »

July 04, 2008

My Amygdala, My Self

Intrigued (and alarmed) by the new science of “neuromarketing,” our correspondent peers into his own brain via an MRI machine and learns what he really thinks about Jimmy Carter, Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, Bruce Springsteen, and Edie Falco.

Jeffrey Goldberg in The Atlantic:

Screenhunter_05_jul_04_1756My friend Bill Knapp, who is a Democratic political consultant and, as such, a man whose devotion to a coherent set of liberal-centrist policy ideas does not waver, at least in public, suggested that I have my head examined, in order to determine whether I was neurologically wired for liberalism or conservatism. My wife asked, with a disconcerting level of enthusiasm, whether this was actually possible.

“Not only is it possible, but I have the perfect person to do it,” Bill said (I’m permitted to quote him because the Goldberg seder is on the record). He told us that a neuroscientist named Marco Iacoboni, who directs UCLA’s Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation Laboratory (it sounds even better in the original German), could scan my brain while showing me images of famous politicians. My brain’s response to these pictures, as recorded by a functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) machine, would uncover my actual inclinations and predispositions by sidestepping the usual inhibition controls that can make focus-group testing unreliable.

I was hesitant, for two reasons. First, I believed that I already possessed a superior grasp of my brain’s division of labor: 30 percent of my brain is obsessed with the Holocaust; an additional 30 percent worries about my children; 10 percent is reserved for status anxiety; 7 percent, The Sopranos; 4 percent, Kurds; 2 percent, Chinese food; and so on. I reserve approximately 6 percent, on good days, for The Atlantic.

In addition, I think about sex, and the New York Yankees.

More here.

Posted by Abbas Raza at 11:57 AM | Permalink

Comments

Check out the Neurophilosophy scienceblogger's take: "Neuroimaging is only just moving toward multivariate analysis...so we're still a very long way away from any real understanding of how hundreds or thousands of modules act in parallel and in concert to generate behaviours..."

Further links to discussion of the Atlantic article and others are in the post linked above.

Posted by: ck | Jul 4, 2008 12:46:44 PM

Wow, what an idiotic article. The function of the MRI here seems to be identical to the rather less expensive crystal ball used by fortune-tellers.

Making up some plausible explanations for why someone's amygdala lights up upon seeing pictures of people whose identities and relationship to the subject are known to the researchers -- particularly when the mark (er, "subject") is right there giving you feedback on your guesses -- is not science, or even pseudo-science. It's just plain old fortune-telling.

The fact that the same "reading" is interpreted in the article to mean two or three mutually contradictory things -- depending on what the subject has to say about that specific photograph -- is pretty conclusive evidence that this technique has zero predictive power, right?

Posted by: Picador | Jul 4, 2008 2:27:16 PM

Post a comment






Subscribe to this blog's feed  

3QD Science Prize

Logo designed by Vicki Winters

Iran Twitter News

Andrew Covers Iran

The Lede on Iran

HuffPo Liveblogging

Help 3 Quarks Daily

3QD on Twitter

Search Using Lijit

Lijit Search

Bookmark This Page

AddThis Social Bookmark Button

3QD FEED FOR GOOGLE


Add to Google

3QD ADVERTISING


Compare prices

  • Canada (French)
  • Australia
  • New Zealand
  • South Africa
  • Brazil
  • Recent Comments

    mr.ed on Saudis give nod to Israeli raid on Iran

    Manas Shaikh on Saudis give nod to Israeli raid on Iran

    Jay on The Bitter Taste of Life

    Louise Gordon on Oh, just watch it!

    Louise Gordon on Oh, just watch it!

    Chris Horner on The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America

    mr.ed on The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America

    aguy109 on The Godfather of American Liberalism

    Jesse M. on The Godfather of American Liberalism

    Sagredo on The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America

    aguy109 on The Godfather of American Liberalism

    aguy109 on Second Life Data Offers Window Into How Trends Spread

    aguy109 on The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America

    beajerry on All quiet on the God front

    Jesse M. on The Godfather of American Liberalism

    Jesse M. on The Godfather of American Liberalism

    Jesse M. on The Godfather of American Liberalism

    J7 on No! Michael Jackson is dead!

    J7 on No! Michael Jackson is dead!

    J7 on No! Michael Jackson is dead!

    ReerbLertutle on OBESITY AND ADDICTION : This is Your Brain on Food

    Zara on The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America

    Dave Ranning on All quiet on the God front

    jean-paul on All quiet on the God front

    Dave Ranning on The unanimous Declaration of the thirteen united States of America

    Acclaim For 3QD

    ------XXX------

    "I couldn't tear myself away from 3 Quarks Daily, to the point of neglecting my work. Congratulations on this superb site."—Steven Pinker, Johnstone Professor of Psychology, Harvard University.

    "I have placed 3 Quarks Daily at the head of my list of web bookmarks."—Richard Dawkins, Charles Simonyi Professor of the Public Understanding of Science at Oxford University.

    "Just wanted you to know I’m one of many who reads and enjoys 3 Quarks....almost daily."—David Byrne, musician, former lead-singer of the Talking Heads, artist, intellectual.

    Subscribe to this blog's feed