March 12, 2008
The Race Is On to Create 'Pink Viagra'
David Segal in the Washington Post:
Where is the women's version of Viagra?
The short answer: They're still working on it. A bunch of companies have tried and failed to create "pink Viagra," as it's often called. Other companies have drugs in late stages of clinical testing, including a gel that recently began a make-or-break nationwide study with several thousand women. Give us five years, maybe less, say the most optimistic researchers and doctors. Though it's unclear exactly how many women would ask for a prescription, no one doubts that the first company that gets to market a remedy for female sexual dysfunction, as it's formally known, will earn a fortune.
But as this race reaches what could be its final lap, not all of the spectators are cheering. Some, in fact, are booing as loudly as they can.
A modest-size but fervent group of psychologists, academics and public health advocates contend that FSD isn't an authentic medical condition, or at least not the sort of problem that should be treated with drugs. These aren't the obtuse male physicians who for decades have been telling women distressed by their lack of libido that "it's all in your head." The anti-FSD crowd is mostly women, many of them self-described feminists. The most prominent is Leonore Tiefer, a psychotherapist and clinical associate professor at New York University, who has long decried what she calls "the medicalization of women's sexuality."
More here. [Thanks to Ruchira Paul.]
Posted by Abbas Raza at 11:59 PM | Permalink










Comments
Sexual dysfunction, we all seem to understand well, is NOT a medical condition, as say happens with appendicitis.
We are running a Red Queen's Race with our lust for expanding the range of our hedonistic pleasure, hoping that we can eat that fifth Wendy's and remain thin --- or if we get fat, as we surely will, that a nice insurance policy will compensate for the health damage we did to ourselves.
What is satisfactory sex? At what age do we speak? Is the person fat, diabetic, psychologically traumatized (whatever that is), or what have you?
You know. We'll find it, soon enough, in DSM-ETC and, when that happens, a pharmaceutical company will come along with a drug that will correct it.
To further understand the medicalization of our culture, the book to read is: "Creating Mental Illness" by A. V. Horwitz.
Posted by: Felix E. F. Larocca MD | Mar 13, 2008 8:43:11 AM
We already have the brand name though.
It will be called "Voracia."
Posted by: Carlos | Mar 13, 2008 8:54:59 AM
"Critics who question the need for a women's version of Viagra"
I'm sorry, but who died and made these critics decide which needs are real and which are fake?
Here's the thing about a free society: if you don't think there's a need for something, don't buy it. If I think there's a need for it, I'll buy it. You can spare me the paternalism.
Frankly, I really do not see the need for pontificating professors to have journal articles written about how they question my need for something.
Posted by: feminist bitch | Mar 14, 2008 2:50:10 AM
Felix,
I don't think you can say with any certainty that "sexual dysfunction is not a medical condition." Instead I think this is a lot more like depression in that the causes are both 'nature' and 'nurture' as well as the interaction between the two. This means that a solution may lie in either one, the other, or both areas, and it will likely vary between individuals and across time. Perhaps counseling would help or perhaps a pill would help (or perhaps just a better lover). The point is that Viagra has helped many men and women deserve the same, no?
Posted by: Barkley | Mar 14, 2008 11:40:32 AM
Barkley, thanks for your thoughtful retort.
When I say that sexual dysfunction is not a medical condition, I am refering to the hodgepodge that makes of it a diagnostic category: DSM-ETC.
This famous "Manual" assembled by Robert Spitzer and his mariachi is both confusing and self-serving.
Now, if viagra helps anyone, it's fine with me. But not as a diagnostic label used to seek reimbursement from your health insurance carrier.
Use it as another sport, like --- let's say --- eating fast food.
If you get an eating disorder (like obesity or bulimia) as result, or if you suffer any of the complications of viagra, let's not share the burden with others and let's not call it a "medical condition"
The book I recommend is: Shyness: How Normal Behavior Became a Sickness by C. Lane.
Posted by: Felix E. F. Larocca MD | Mar 15, 2008 4:10:14 AM
Post a comment