December 17, 2007
A Case of the Mondays: List of Most Underrated Things
To complement my list of most overrated things, here's my list of the most underrated things in the same categories. The same rules apply: everything I recommend has to be significantly worse-known or less supported than it should be.
Literature: Pushkin. In Eastern Europe he's of course not underrated, but here in the US surprisingly many people haven't read Eugene Onegin.
Leaders: Hamilton. At a time when common wisdom was all about free trade and agricultural wealth, he favored industry and nurtured it with protective tariffs. Jean Chretien, whose austerity program was one of the few that either balanced the budget or promoted growth, and the only one that did both. And Seretse Khama, the only postcolonial leader whose country has remained democratic since independence (though his economic record is conversely overrated: Botswana may have a five-figure GDP per capita, but its social development is disappointing, especially when compared to South Africa's).
Political movements: third-world liberalism. Because of Singh and Lula, it's in charge in the majority of the democratic world by population, but in the first world people are dismally ignorant of it, arbitrarily assigning its leaders to either neoliberalism or populism.
Political issues: urban planning. Surprisingly many social problems, such as American and French race riots, owe a lot to dreadful urban planning, which created the modern ghetto.
Linguistics: the comparative method. It's painstaking and not very sexy, but it teaches us things about ancient cultures that we could never learn otherwise due to lack of writing and paucity of archeological data.
Science: chemistry. For some reason it makes a lot fewer headlines than physics or biology, but it's at least as forward-looking and important; a cheap way of manufacturing carbon nanotubes would do more to change the world than anything molecular biology's achieved so far. Biochemistry is of course not underrated, but anything else in chemsitry is.
Economics: import replacement. Every country that's become developed - the US, Germany, Japan, South Korea, Israel, Taiwan - has used it, often with protective tariffs on manufactured goods and restrictions on capital flight. One-way free trade, where developed countries open their markets to third-world goods without expecting reciprocation; this underlay much of South Korea and Taiwan and post-war Germany's success. And the German economic model, which looks worse than it is only because in 1990 West Germany inherited twenty million people's worth of a second-world country.
Social science: Cultural Theory of Risk. It's a robust theory that explains social attitudes better than anything else that's been tested, and that very few people outside anthropology and cultural geography seem to have heard of.
Philosophy: Thomas Kuhn. His ideas about the philosophy of science contain many sharp observations, which a lot of positivists ignore for purely ideological reasons.
Popular science: I'm going to go out on a limb and say Wikipedia. Popular science books always give me the impression that they leave out any example that's inconvenient for the author's thesis; Wikipedia instead is inherently messy and comes off as trying to teach rather than enchant.
Music: Vanessa Carlton. A lot of radio stations refused to play White Houses only because it has a mature view of sex and relationships, and because it's not exactly the same as A Thousand Miles.
Television: The Wire. It has the depth of a literary novel and portrays politics more realistically than The West Wing, police work more realistically than any police show, crime more realistically than Oz.
Food: Indian. The range and taste of Indian cuisine is far better than what you'd expect from eating at the places in the US that pass for Indian, but even so they're almost the only outside places I'm willing to spend money eating at. And small delis, whose sandwiches tend to be cheap and good enough that it's a wonder Subway's still in business.
Media: Al-Jazeera. Westerners seem to hate it only because it's Middle Eastern, even though its production values are on a par with those of CNN and the BBC. If it were a British or Japanese station, Donald Rumsfeld and Fox News would've never slandered it by saying it shows footage of beheadings.
Books: Jane Jacobs. Her writings about cities are as relevant as ever, but for some reason, the only thing the political establishment has taken from her is that razing neighborhoods to build highways is a bad idea; that was never her main point, and much of today's transit-oriented development is as poorly planned as urban renewal projects.
Academics: merit admissions. They're arbitrary and often nonsensical, but also far harder to game by enterprising aristocrats and legacies. And before you tell me about diversity, compare the demographics of Berkeley and Columbia (Columbia's a lot whiter).
Posted by Alon Levy at 05:47 AM | Permalink





Comments
Dear Alon,
I've greatly enjoyed these capricious (and sometimes provocative) lists of yours. Here are my few additions:
Literature: Robert Musil, the least well known of the Joyce-Proust-Musil modernist triad.
Science: Computer Science. Things like huge advances in computing algorithms never get much attention, and figures like Donald Knuth and Douglas Lenat are basically unknown to the public. It also lacks a big prize like the Fields Medal which would produce public name recognition. Maybe.
Philosophy: Rorty. Few understand the depth of his ideas. I wish I had met him, though I did correspond with him briefly before he died. If you haven't read Philosophy and the Mirror of Nature, do so.
Popular Science: The "Introducing _____" series of graphic books like "Introducing Quantum Theory." I love the audacity of the idea of explaining things like Quantum Theory in a comic book, with knowledgable people writing the text, and very beautifully whimsical illustrations. Well, they're kind of fun to read!
Music: Nusrat Fateh Ali Khan. One of the greatest master singers of our time remains unknown to most except Pakistanis and Indians--and their dragged-to-Nusrat-concerts friends.
Food: Sri Lankan. Sri Lankan food is to Indian what Thai food is to Chinese--more spicy and with a refreshing twist. If you haven't tried Sigiri on 1st between 5th and 6th, do. (Next to the Indian places with all the chillie-lights.) And, of course, Pakistani food!
Books: The Golden Gate by Vikram Seth. IMHO Seth is probably the only subcontinental writer of fiction in the same league as Naipaul or Rushdie, and this is a wonderful little novel written in verse which tells a very interesting story. Robin made me read it years ago.
Drop me an email sometime and let me know what you're up to...
Posted by: Abbas Raza | Dec 17, 2007 6:53:20 AM
Alon,
As a practicing linguist I appreciate your nod to the fruits of the profession...but really? the comparative method teaches us "things" about ancient cultures? What have you learned about ancient Cebuanos by reconstructing Proto-Austronesian?
Abbas,
Please visit Udupi, Karnataka.
Posted by: Chandan | Dec 17, 2007 8:54:34 AM
The Kinks are the most underrated band that I'm aware of.
Posted by: anonymous | Dec 17, 2007 9:11:32 AM
Never thought I'd see the day I saw Kuhn called "underrated"
Posted by: D | Dec 17, 2007 9:39:06 AM
I'm totally underrated!
Posted by: Paris Hilton | Dec 17, 2007 10:44:07 AM
Al-Jazeera--
Chemistry-
Cultural Theory of Risk--
I agree.
Risk, Improbability, and Chemistry seem to dominate the path I have been wandering down lately.
Kinks? well maybe.
Mitochondria are very underrated.
Posted by: Dave Ranning | Dec 17, 2007 12:21:10 PM
Now this is an interesting list...Thanks Alon.
Posted by: Pete Chapman | Dec 17, 2007 2:50:07 PM
I couldn't continue with the overrated list after I saw the idiotic inclusion of Shakespeare--who cannot be overrated. But I am totally with you on Hamilton. I adore Hamilton. He is the mac daddy of founding fathers. His wisdom, intelligence, foresight, understanding of human nature, vision, and integrity is unmatched in that generation--and that is fucking saying something!!
Posted by: Bryon | Dec 17, 2007 4:53:55 PM
Here's a link to a decent interview with Hamilton's most recent biographer, Ron Chernow:
http://www.hoover.org/multimedia/uk/2939161.html
Posted by: Bryon | Dec 17, 2007 4:59:18 PM
A Case of the Mondays: Totally Underrated!!
Posted by: Holly | Dec 17, 2007 5:41:50 PM
Hamilton is underrated-- as a totalitarian elitist.
Shakespeare is overrated-- I thought I was the only one who thought so. I enjoy his plays, but is in the shallow end of the pool compared to Chaucher, or even Beckett.
Posted by: Dave Ranning | Dec 17, 2007 9:12:12 PM
Literature: The Autocrat of the Breakfast Table, By O. W. Holmes;
Leaders: John Quincy Adams
Political Figure: Thomas Paine
Music: Gentle Giant, Schnittke, Alan Hovhanes, Sandy Denny
Television: Battlestar Galactica
Film: O Brother, Where Art Thou?
Posted by: cyork | Dec 18, 2007 9:06:18 AM
I bet the Hoover Institution loved Hamilton--
Here are some of it's members (from Wiki)--
"The Hoover Institution is influential in the American conservative and libertarian movements, and the Institution has long been a place of scholarship for high profile conservatives with government experience. A number of fellows have connections to or positions in the Bush administration, and other Republican administrations. On September 8, 2007 the Hoover Institution announced that former secretary of defense Donald Rumsfeld had accepted an invitation to join the institution as a one-year visiting fellow [2] [3]. A non-political figure who played a key role in the Bush Administration's Iraq policy, Retired Army Gen. John P. Abizaid, former commander of the U.S. Central Command (CENTCOM), recently joined the Hoover Institution (as the first Annenberg Distinguished Visiting Fellow) [4]. Other fellows of the Institution include such high profile conservatives as Condoleezza Rice, George Shultz, Newt Gingrich, Thomas Sowell, Dinesh D'Souza, Shelby Steele, Edwin Meese and Pete Wilson. Since 2001, Hoover has published Policy Review."
Posted by: Dave Ranning | Dec 19, 2007 12:34:37 PM
Post a comment