June 12, 2005
Chomsky on Language and Rights
In the recent issue of The Boston Review, Noam Chomsky discusses what he's usually reluctant to discuss, on the unversailty of language and rights, and (a little) on the possible connections.
"With each step toward principled explanation in these [genetic, experiental, and computational] terms, we gain a clearer grasp of the universals of language. It should be kept in mind, however, that any such progress still leaves unresolved problems that have been raised for hundreds of years. Among these are the mysterious problems of the creative and coherent ordinary use of language, a core problem of Cartesian science.
* * *
We are now moving to domains of will and choice and judgment, and the thin strands that may connect what seems within the range of scientific inquiry to essential problems of human life, in particular vexed questions about universal human rights. One possible way to draw connections is by proceeding along the lines of Hume’s remarks that I mentioned earlier: his observation that the unbounded range of moral judgments—like the unbounded range of linguistic knowledge—must be founded on general principles that are part of our nature though they lie beyond our 'original instincts,' which elsewhere he took to include the 'species of natural instincts' on which knowledge and belief are grounded."
Posted by Robin Varghese at 01:44 PM | Permalink
TrackBack
TrackBack URL for this entry: http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341c562c53ef00d8347e8b1b69e2
Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Chomsky on Language and Rights:





Comments
Should a customer also have a "right" not to be forced to listen to a telephone "greeting" of a business in many languages before being permitted to talk to an actual person in customer service? Just imagine how long it would take just to get past this if the politically correct business sought to placate all the estimated 3,000 to 8,000 spoken languages in the world! For example, suppose it took about an average of 3 seconds to say "hello" in each of say 3,600 languages. Since there are 60 seconds per minute and 60 minutes per hour, this means there are 3,600 seconds per hour, so multiplying 3 seconds times the number of languages 3,600 and dividing by 3,600 seconds per hour yields a 3 hour wait just to get past "hello"! The telephone lines would be jammed, and millions or billions of dollars would have to be spent to install more telephone cable to accomodate the traffic.
Posted by: Winfield J. Abbe | Jun 13, 2005 7:31:04 AM
Post a comment